Bullet Points on 16 Approaches to Homeschooling

Dear Reader,

Recently I published my “Find your approach to homeschooling quiz.” If you took the quiz, you hopefully now have a short list of homeschooling methods to consider. To help you in that endeavor, I would like to share with you now my own list of bullet points on each of the 16 approaches I considered in that quiz. These were my working notes as I developed the quiz. They are by no means a complete introduction to all the many ways to educate your children, but I share them with you in the hopes that they can help you get a quick feel for each of the philosophies. If you are looking for more information, check out my resources page here.

Nebby

Bullet Points on 16 Approaches to Homeschooling

School-at-home

  • the parent/teacher teaches either one student or a group of students
  • the job of the teacher is primarily to teach, that is, to impart knowledge
  • teacher-directed learning
  • the material learned is fairly traditional – the 3Rs plus history and science; STEM subjects may be emphasized
  • the focus is primarily intellectual with more artsy pursuits taking at least a second seat
  • textbooks and worksheets are used
  • learning is measured through testing
  • learning is done for its own sake; whether one likes it is of secondary importance
  • the goal is to be educated so as to make one’s way in society, get a good job, get into college, be “successful”
  • the child is shaped by the teacher, through education, to be like adults/fit into society

Online/distance learning

  • very similar to school-at-home
  • the job of the teacher/curriculum is primarily to teach, that is, to impart knowledge
  • the student may interact with one teacher, one teacher and a group of students, or just with the materials
  • traditional subjects, likely with a heavy emphasis on the STEM subjects
  • the appeal is primarily to the mind
  • fairly traditional teaching tools, but obviously with an online/technology-driven twist
  • learning is likely measured through testing
  • learning is done for its own sake; whether one likes it is of secondary importance
  • the goal is to be educated so as to make one’s way in society, get a good job, get into college, be “successful”
  • the child is shaped through education to be like adults/fit into society

Classical/Great Books

  • the parent/teacher imparts knowledge
  • the teacher interacts with one student or a group of students
  • the material is fairly traditional with an emphasis on classic literature which often includes real classical classics (think Homer, Plutarch)
  • there is a core body of knowledge all people should know
  • the focus is primarily intellectual with more artsy pursuits taking a second seat though there may be some inclusion of art history and the like
  • learning is through great books but also through memorization of facts, especially in the early years
  • learning may be measured through testing
  • learning is done for its own sake; whether one likes it is of secondary importance
  • the goal is to be educated in order to make one’s way and even to excel in society. There is a sense of “those who do not know history are doomed to repeat it” so that those who get such an education will contribute to society/be good citizens as well.
  • the child is shaped by the teacher, through education, to be like adults
  • the child goes through stages of development: the earliest years are for taking in facts, the middle years for getting context, and the last years for rhetoric, that is, learning to argue one’s position
  • learning is teacher-directed. There is a goal or ideal of what an educated person is and the child is moved toward that ideal
  • there is a sense in which children are not complete; they need to learn to reason and develop abilities

Christian Classical

  • same as classical/great books, with an added Christian slant:
  • there is a sense of adults know best and discipline is likely not a bad word in such a household
  • there may be an added or greater emphasis on being virtuous

Charlotte Mason

  • the parent/teacher selects materials but it is up to the child to “ingest” them
  • learning is done by the child and cannot be forced
  • the role of the teacher is minimized
  • implicit assumption that some materials are better than others
  • heavy reliance upon “living books” with nature study in addition for science
  • handicrafts and physical education are included, but not as a part of the main study
  • a broad education is the goal with a balance of history, science literature, and arts
  • ideas are the food of the mind and are emphasized over facts
  • all truth is God’s truth – which means that we can find truth in non-Christian sources
  • the Holy Spirit is the real educator
  • there is little formal education before age 6 or 7
  • play is not part of education but free time (“masterly inactivity”) is valued
  • motivation should be internal; we because of an innate love of learning; we don’t need to make it “fun”
  • “Children are born persons” – the assumption is that all children can learn and are born equipped to learn
  • though there is a generally positive view of children as made in the image of God, there is also an acknowledgment that they need habit-training
  • the goal of education is to “set their feet in a wide place,” that is to give them connections with a lot of different things
  • re goals: we ask not how much they know, but how much they care

Thomas Jefferson Education

  • the teacher is mentor; the teacher is important; his job is to inspire (“inspire, not require”)
  • the teacher and student have a one-on-one relationship
  • the child cannot rise above the mentor
  • the child can pursue interests but the teacher’s role is still vital
  • greatness inspires greatness
  • classic, living books; not textbooks, no busywork
  • no one set curriculum though classics and living books are valued
  • there are stages in a child’s development; no formal education till age 8 or so
  • children have an inner genius but there is also the idea that younger children are not yet equipped for real learning
  • motivation is internal and love of learning is a goal
  • leadership education; training leaders is a goal
  • the goals are at least in part societal
  • a certain set of values (freedom, democracy) are assumed

Montessori

  • teacher as guide
  • the teacher creates the environment for learning
  • originally developed for children with developmental issues
  • children explore at their pace within the created environment
  • children will develop appropriately in the right environment – implies that children need to develop and that the teacher is essential in creating the right environment
  • the environment is controlled and scaled down for children
  • there are stages in a child’s development
  • the last stage is to influence the world and be a leader
  • one goal for M. Montessori was world peace

Waldorf

  • in the early years, the teacher is an example because children learn through imitation
  • lots of arts and specialized movement (“activity always precedes headwork”)
  • no books in early education but songs and finger-plays
  • in later years good books are included and subjects are studied in chunks, ie a few weeks on history, then a few on science and so on
  • no textbooks
  • children create their own coursebooks as a way of cementing learning
  • children are whole people
  • people are spiritual beings
  • each one has a specific life purpose
  • children are fundamentally different from adults
  • though there are stages, the idea is that children evolve as they grow
  • in high school, being well-balanced is a goal but so is pursuing individual interests
  • goal: “to produce individuals who are able, in and of themselves, to impart meaning to their lives”

Enki

  • teachers are cornerstones and examples
  • in the schools, in early years, two teachers and a class of kids; but can be a parent and child
  • security and variety; very nurturing and gentle approach
  • the rhythm of learning is important
  • physical and hands-on/arts activities are integral
  • arts-based; all academics are introduced through the arts
  • stages of development but with a sense of evolving, as a caterpillar into a butterfly
  • the central task: “the integration of body, heart, and mind within each child and parent”
  • societal goals, concern for the global community
  • whole person education: body, heart, mind
  • connectedness and confidence are goals
  • goal: meaningful connections with the larger world

Unit Studies

  • all subjects ate studied around a common theme which could be based on one book or be a theme like knights or apples or really anything
  • the burden is on the teacher to tie all subjects together
  • education should be fun, interesting, enjoyable
  • there seems to be some assumption that the child cannot but that the teacher can
  • themes could be child selected but there is still a large role for the teacher

Ruth Beechick

  • parent/teacher as tutor
  • one-on-one teaching
  • “teach the child, not the book”
  • individualized education; not one core curriculum
  • real books, not textbooks for history but also one should not be too “bookish”
  • teachers provide a rich learning environment
  • no busywork
  • if it is boring, the fault is in the curriculum, not the child; implies curriculum should be made enjoyable/fun
  • basic skills must be mastered so further learning can occur
  • pre-K and K don’t need schooling
  • information should be processed in some way leads to hands-on projects, real life activities
  • can use unit studies
  • thinking skills are taught and learned – this implies that there is some development in the child

(Radical) Unschooling

  • the role of the teacher is minimal
  • though learning is initiated by the child, the parent may help in finding resources
  • learning is done by the child
  • there is no one set of material that everyone needs to know
  • very individualized
  • child-led learning
  • the child will learn what they need when they need it
  • there is an inherent belief in the child’s goodness and ability to select what is right for him
  • often combined with the disciplinary view that the adult should not impose their will on the child
  • goals can vary greatly but are likely to include allowing the child to be an individual, find himself, find his passion

Moore Method Homeschooling

  • parents are the best teachers
  • manual work as much as studying plus household work or community service
  • fewer workbooks and textbooks, but drills are used
  • no formal education before at least age 8
  • learning also happens through real life activities
  • the best motivation is internal
  • goals: high achievement, responsibility, sociability

Robinson Curriculum

  • self-education, but with a set curriculum
  • almost no teacher interaction, but the curriculum and study environment are very important
  • uses high quality books; learning is through books, almost exclusively
  • core subjects are taught: math, LA, science, history
  • “they teach themselves to think”
  • goals are academic and learning to think, self-educate

Accelerated Learning

  • geared to the whole person, understood in a very scientific sense
  • activity based learning
  • students collaborate
  • real world contexts are important
  • positive environment is essential
  • goals: “success”, “excel”

Reggio Emilia

  • focuses on early years (preschool and primary) only
  • the teacher facilitates based on the child’s interests
  • children’s interests are important; self-guided learning
  • children have “a hundred languages”; are knowledge bearers
  • heavily reliance on the arts
  • environment is important
  • long term projects are vehicles for learning
  • relationships are important as is the community
  • goal: to develop one’s potential

(Biblical) Principle Approach

  • there are principles which underlie everything and these are the goal of education, not facts
  • the principles are assumed to be biblical principles
  • “There is no better textbook than the Bible.”
  • emphasis on “America’s Christian history”
  • the process of education is found in the 4R’s: research, reason, relate and record.
  • A teacher with students like a rabbi with disciples
  • the teacher’s role is important; the teacher is the living book
  • no worksheets
  • individuality is appreciated but it is also believed that there are right answers
  • a fairly high, positive view of human nature and reason
  • idea of personal calling
  • a societal goal as well: “What did you do to secure freedom and proliferate it while it was in your power to do so?”

 

Advertisements

3 responses to this post.

  1. […] Bullet Points on 16 Approaches to Homeschooling […]

    Reply

  2. […] there, you can check out my Bullet Points on 16 Approaches to Homeschooling and Resources on 17 Approaches to […]

    Reply

  3. […] homeschooling approach. I tried to look particularly at the philosophy behind each approach (and I considered 16 of them). If I apply this quiz to deschooling, I find that its answers pretty much line up with those of […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Sabbath Mood Homeschool

Desiring That a Sabbath Mood Rest on Your Homeschool

dayuntoday

my musings, wise or otherwise

Festival Fete

locally grown art, food, and merriment

StrongHaven

A Literary Homestead

journey-and-destination

Blogging about education, theology, and more

Harmony Fine Arts

Blogging about education, theology, and more

The Common Room

....Blogging about cabbages and kings since 2005.

Sage Parnassus

Blogging about education, theology, and more

A peaceful day

Blogging about education, theology, and more

Living Charlotte Mason in California

Blogging about education, theology, and more

weeklywalrus

Weekly Walrus Whatevers

Creations by Maris

Craft Projects For all Ages

Fisher Academy International ~ Teaching Home

Blogging about education, theology, and more

Afterthoughts

Blogging about education, theology, and more

Leah's Bookshelf

Book Reviews You Can Trust

Duxbury Art Boosters

Supporting the visual arts in Duxbury Public Schools

Just Right Porridge

... you'll lick your bowl clean...